Legislative Concerns
Due Process Ignored
Concern:
The amendments undermine the principles of fair trial and legal safeguards, leading to potential abuses of power.
Bill of Rights Ignored
Concern:
The law conflicts with protections
outlined in New Zealand’s
Bill of Rights Act 1990 (BORA).
Human Rights
Ignored
Concern:
The most basic of all rights
Tossed out the window
Warnings Ignored
Concern:
Expert advice and community consultations have been dismissed or inadequately addressed.
Public Consequences
Concern:
The law may fail to achieve its intended outcomes while creating long-term societal harms.
Other Legislative Concerns
Overreach:
• Expansive definitions of "gang affiliation" risk criminalizing individuals who are not involved in illegal activities, such as family members or associates.
International Reputation:
• Human rights organizations may criticize New Zealand for adopting regressive policies, damaging its standing as a progressive nation.
Disproportionate Powers:
Law enforcement agencies are granted sweeping powers that may be misused, leading to over-policing of minority communities.
Cost vs. Benefit:
• Increased policing and legal enforcement come at a high taxpayer cost, with no guarantee of tangible results.
Conclusion
​While addressing gang violence is a legitimate goal, the current legislative approach prioritizes punitive measures over fairness, rehabilitation, and long-term solutions. Policymakers must reconsider these laws to ensure they align with New Zealand’s values of justice, equity, and human rights.